_MOVIES  
 

THE MOTHMAN PROPHECIES
A Screen Gems & Lakeshore Entertainment release 

review by Joseph B. Mauceri

xmenposterSYNOPSIS: Based on the true events in Point Pleasant, Virginia, as chronicled in John Keel's book of the same title, The Mothman Prophecies, examines a series of inexplicable occurrences through the eyes - and mind - of John Klien (Richard Gere). Klien is driven to extremes to investigate the mysterious circumstances surrounding his wife's death - and how they might be connected to the strange phenomena in a town four hundred miles away. A respected Washington Post journalist at the top of his game, while removing his wife's possessions from the hospital, he remembers her last words: "You didn't see it, did you?" Then he discovers a sketchpad covered with odd drawings, variations of the same eerie apparition. A couple of years later, while driving one night from Washington to Richmond for an assignment, he loses his way and ends up on a deserted country highway. His car inexplicably breaks down. The owner of a nearby farmhouse threatens Klien and tells him he has been waiting for him. Sgt. Connie Parker (Laura Linney) arrives on the scene and divulges to him that the entire county is on the edge due to a recent series of odd disturbances. John finally realizes that he is in Point Pleasant, West Virginia -- four hundred miles from where he thought he was. How? His curiosity piqued, John decides to stay in Point Pleasant to explore the reports of unexplained phenomena. He soon realizes that they may all be related, not just to each other, but also to the strange sketches Mary had been obsessively drawing just hours before her death. But what exactly is the connection? The events defy simple explanation and, more disturbing, seem to predict impending disasters. The more he unravels, the more John begins to question his own sanity. Are there unknown forces behind the strange sightings? What terrible thing awaits the people of Point Pleasant? For John, it's a race against time to figure it out, and try to prevent something terrible from happening.

REVIEW: The power of THE MOTHMAN PROPHECIES as a film can be directly attributed to the unique cinematic narrative style of director Mark Pellington. Over the years, Mark has focused on combing words and images to create highly engaging and surreal experiences for the viewer. The director creates secure and familiar situations that allow an audience to invest an emotional interest. He then slowly begins to manipulate that reality, reminding us just how fragile it is. In 1992 he created "The Memory Palace," a five-screen live-action evocation of the cyberspace, in conjunction with sci-fi guru William Gibson for the World Expo in Spain. In 1999 he unleashed his extremely dark political thriller "Arlington Road." THE MOTHMAN PROPHECIES offers Mark a unique combination of urban myth and a strong character study to show audiences the full extent of his cinematic prowess.

The film takes a few liberties with the novel in order to make the story more viewer friendly. The novel is slightly darker, and I think Pellington makes a wise call given the response to the rather bleak outlook he presented in "Arlington Road." The director is skilled at obtaining powerful performances from his cast that forcefully drives the suspense and tension as well as the best visual effects. He trims down the characters so that the film focuses on the journey of John Klein (Gere). The plot is conservative in its presentation of Klein's life prior to the tragic events, and as such leaves little for actress Debra Messing, who plays his wife, to offer us in the way of a performance. Laura Linney, an exceptional actress, is Gere's female counterpart, delivering a performance that allows this secondary character to standout in the tale. Likewise, Will Patton, a talented character actor, possesses that everyman ability of a Jimmy Stewart that permits the viewer to sympathize for his character's descent into madness.

Like any good monster movie, Pellington keeps the Mothman shrouded in shadows. It is that thing just lurking beyond our perception that is the most frightening of all. Several times we are offered quick glimpses of him, but any hard representation is kept to the drawings of those who have actually witnessed him. There are times when the director employees all the tools of his trade to create a sense of tension that makes the viewer aware of this entity's presence. What exactly is the Mothman? Pellington offers several explanations: Alien, Time Traveler, Angel, Demon, etc., but draws no firm conclusions. We are empowered with the ability to draw our own conclusions based on the information presented.

Pellington's work in the music video industry has given him a keen since of images and score. As powerful as any of the performances is the score by tomandandy. It is a musical composition that skillfully walks the line between traditional and techno. There is no real Mothman theme, but there are key elements to the composition that allows the viewer to identify the music with the character, and offers the composers greater freedom in combining elements then a traditional score. In essences it becomes this additional organic element of the film that intensifies the suspense.

Since M. Night Shyamalan gave use the character driven genre thriller "The Sixth Sense" in 1999, some wise fillmakers have picked up on the key element of a successful genre film -- characters over effects. In 2001, films like "Session 9," "The Devil's Backbone" and most recently "Brotherhood of the Wolf" have continued to prove that universal truth. Pellington's cinematic interpretation of THE MOTHMAN PROPHECIES offers audiences a proficiently crafted urban thriller that loosens the underpinnings of reality, without spiraling it into the realm of the unbelievable.  More then your basic scary movie, THE MOTHMAN PROPHECIES brings the terror home. Pellington delivers a film that earns him a place next to such suspense legends as Hitchcock and Craven.

OFFICIAL WEB SITE:
http://www.spe.sony.com/movies/mothman/

BACK



OVERALL WORTH 
based on a Manhattan price 
of $9.50
STORY $9.00
ACTING $8.00
DIRECTING $9.50
PRODUCTION
DESIGN 
$9.50
SPECIAL
EFFECTS 
$9.50
SCORE/MUSIC
SONGS
$9.50
"REAL" VALUE $9.17

SUMMARY:
"All the President's Men" meets "Communion" in a highly unsettling exploration of reality that outshines even the best episode of "The X-Files."

CREDITS:

CREW
Director - Mark Pellington; Based on the novel by John A. Keel; Screenplay - Richard Hatem; Producers - Gary W. Goldstein, Gary Lucchesi & Tom Rosenberg; Cinematographer - Fred Murphy; Score - tomandandy (Tom Hajdu & Andy Milburn); Production Design - Richard Hoover; Art Direction - Troy Sizemore; Special Effects Supervisor - Peter Chesney; Visual Effects - Cinsite.

CAST
RICHARD GERE... John Klein; LAURA LINNEY... Connie Parker; WILL PATTON... Gordon Smallwood; DEBRA MESSING... Mary Klein; LUCINDA JENNEY... Denise Smallwood; ALAN BATES... Alexander Leek; NESBITT BLAISDELL... Chief Josh Jarrett; DAN CALLAHAN... C.J.; MURPHY DUNNE... Governor Rob McCallum; BILL LANG... Ingrid Cole; ROHN THOMAS... Dr. Williams.